Thursday, November 22, 2018

Why I Worry


In May of 2017, after the bombing of the concert in Manchester, UK, where teen girls were killed and maimed by an Islamic terrorist, I wrote a post Our Children (https://commonsense-mark.blogspot.com/2017/05/our-children.html).  That post was my most read post on my blog.  In it, I asserted that a civilization that lacks the will to protect and nurture its children is in deep trouble.

My fears have not been allayed, and rather have gotten much worse.  The very institutions that have been set up to protect children have either been hijacked to exploit them, or have enabled their exploitation.  

First, in a stunning decision, a Detroit judge ruled that a federal law under which Muslim doctors were performing female genital mutilations were prosecuted was unconstitutional, stating “as laudable as the prohibition of a particular type of abuse of girls may be, it does not further the goal of protecting children on a nondiscriminatory basis.”  Of course, the defense attorneys in that case argued their position on 1st amendment grounds --- freedom of religion.  In Judge Friedman’s eyes, not discriminating against a barbaric religious practice trumps the protection of these girls.  The judge relied on the commerce clause to throw out the charges, reasoning that their practice did not involve interstate commerce that could be regulated by the federal government.  But some of the girls were brought in from Minnesota, and if growing wheat on your own land that you sell in state (Wicker v. Filburn) is interstate commerce, how can your business of disfiguring girls from another state not be?  This decision is yet another instance of our legal system bending over backwards to accommodate this most barbaric and medieval procedure practiced in some corners of Islam.  Ironically, the ACLU teamed up with Maine Democrats to defeat a measure which would have made female genital mutilation illegal in Maine, arguing that it was already covered by federal law.  So much for that.  This most misogynist practice must be driven from our land, utterly, entirely and without question and citizens who engage in its practice need to be jailed and noncitizens deported. 

Also this week, former Michigan State president Lou Anna Simon was charged with 2 felonies and 2 misdemeanors for lying to investigators in the Larry Nassar abuse case.  It will be recalled that Nasser sexually abused dozens of young female athletes at MSU while serving as a team physician.  Last May, the university reached a $500 million settlement with the 332 victims (the Wall Street Journal reported that a bankruptcy filing was considered to deal with the claims).  Simon knew.  Other people working in the athletic department knew (including a gymnastics coach that was also charged.  Many of those are still working at MSU. 

The primary purpose of a university is to educate and shape young people so they can flourish in adult life.   The entire structure at MSU failed to protect these young female athletes from this monster, who will now carry the scars of Nassar’s abuse for the rest of their lives.   Most infuriating about this whole sick episode in higher education is that it was a female leader of an institution that enabled the exploitation of young women.

Finally, the Vatican is at it again.  Months after Cardinal McCarrick resigned amidst the sex abuse scandal in the Catholic Church and the grand jury report concerning the Pittsburgh Archdiocese was released, the Vatican blocked an effort by U.S. bishops to put forward a plan to curb abuse, ordering them to wait.  Wait for what, exactly?  A better plan by a Vatican that honored Cardinal Law?

Worse, in Chicago, Cardinal Cupich downplayed the furor by arrogantly dismissing it, “We have a bigger agenda than to be distracted by all of this.”   Again, what bigger agenda?  What could possibly be more important and urgent than protecting our children?

I do not wish to take on the role of Chicken Little, but you can see that our societal structures whose MOST IMPORTANT PURPOSE is to protect young people are failing them miserably, and indeed have become vehicles through which they are being exploited and abused.

If this corruption is not addressed, it does not bode well for us.

No comments:

Post a Comment